gordon.coale
 
Home
 


Weblog Archives

   
 
  Thursday  June 7  2007    01: 10 AM

iraq

Evolving Tactics in Iraq
by Patrick Lang


As Clausewitz observed, war itself is the best teacher. This war has gone on so long that even those who were zealous but unskilled have "been to school" on American forces for so long that they have learned to so all the things mentioned in this article. When this is combined with the cadres provided by the former Iraqi armed forces, there emerges a "heady" brew endlessly capable of learning, adapting and improvising.

The Post story about the action fought by US SF and the Iraqi police recounts the relative incapacity of the police vis a vis the insurgents. If it had not been for American leadership in this engagement, the insurgents would probably have "bagged" the lot.

An interesting note in this story is the factoid that although the gadgetry developed by Meigs' IED Defeat Task Force is effective, the number of casualties is still rising because the insurgents are building and installing ever more IEDS, many of which are truly huge. So far the US has spent something over 3 billion dollars on the IED problem.

[more]


The "surge" is not doing well.
by Patrick Lang


Yes, Kevin, the war is a contest of wills. Having said that, it is also true that American popular support for the war will not continue if the methods being used do not appear to be effective.

So far, there is little non-PR evidence that the Kagan/Keane/Petraeus plan is "clearing" Baghdad of insurgent and militia control.

If that continues into September, the war will lose so much support that a catastrophic ending will become inevitable.

[more]


US Can Forget About Winning in Iraq: Top Retired General


The man who commanded US-led coalition forces during the first year of the Iraq war says the United States can forget about winning the war.

[more]